Corporate & Commercial

Contracts, structures and governance for businesses that need the paperwork to hold when something goes wrong.

Mergers & Acquisitions

Buying or selling a business, from the term sheet and due diligence through to completion and the restraints that follow.

Read about it

Litigation & Dispute Resolution

Commercial disputes in the NSW, ACT and Federal courts, resolved early where that is possible and run properly where it is not.

Read about it

More of what we do

Property

Wills and Estates

Industries we act for

International Service

Government and Defence

Supplying government and the defence industry.

Read about it

Technology and Software

Your product scales digitally. Your contracts have to scale with it.

Read about it

Financial Services

A regulated business, on solid legal footing.

Read about it

Also live

Real Estate and Construction

Retail, Trade and Consumer Goods

Transport, Logistics and Shipping

Legal Administration Assistant, Canberra

Canberra office, full time, on site.

Read about it

Wahlstation for German Referendare

Sydney or Canberra, open all year.

Read about it

More about working here

Our people

The track record

What we write

The track record

Judgments and tribunal outcomes, transactions completed, appointments taken, and the conversations we are part of in Australia and in Germany.

Read about it

Latest, and longer form

Modern award coverage: what a high salary does not buy

Pathological arbitration clauses in Singapore

Auditor liability in Singapore and Australia

Guide: company constitutions

Guide: shareholder agreements

Germany

A German desk for businesses moving between Australia and the German-speaking market.

Read about it

Singapore

Singapore law where it governs the contract, and the arbitral seat that carries much of the region’s work.

Read about it

Vietnam

Market entry, supply arrangements and dispute resolution for Vietnam.

Read about it

Worth reading first

Vietnam arbitration

Defective arbitration clauses in Singapore

European privacy law for Australian business

Award coverage for German employers

COURT AND TRIBUNAL

Cooper v Myrtace Consulting: leave for a derivative action refused

14 May 2014

A shareholder applied under section 237 of the Corporations Act for leave to bring proceedings in the company’s name against its sole director, alleging misappropriation of the proceeds of a share sale, an improper issue of shares to himself, and a failure to wind the company up.

The Federal Court refused leave and ordered the applicant to pay the company’s costs: Cooper v Myrtace Consulting Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 480. An applicant has to satisfy all five criteria in section 237, and the one that decided the case was whether the proposed action was in the best interests of the company.

The Court accepted there was a serious question to be tried on three of the pleaded claims and none on the rest. Leave still failed, because the applicant could not offer the company a meaningful indemnity for the costs it would be exposed to. Matters put as reasons the director should not be shielded by the corporate form, being unlodged tax returns and financial records not kept, were not pleaded and could not supply the criterion that was missing.

Read the judgment: AustLII

WHERE THIS SITS

Corporate and commercial Commercial litigation

Back to the track record